Ask the Desk: “Razor Fine” Fountain Pens

Pen comparison

Reader Phil asks:

Can you recommend five or so “razor fine” nibs/pens? I am always looking for a good razor fine nib. Is the TWSBI one of them?

The first thing to know is that European and American pen manufacturers use a different criteria for nib widths than the Japanese manufacturers. A Lamy pen labelled as a fine nib is going to create a wider stroke than a Pilot pen that is also labelled as a fine nib.

That said, my best recommendation for razor fine fountain pens are all Japanese made. Pilot makes an XF nib that is very fine. My Pilot Prera is a fine nib as is my Pilot FP 78g and they both create the finest line widths of all the pens in my collection. I’d compare it to a sub-0.5mm (0.38, etc) stroke if you want to compare it to a gel or rollerball measurement.

The TWSBI 540/580 and the Mini both use a European nib. When I initially purchased my TWSBI Mini, I ordered it with a fine nib instead of an XF nib and it was too wide for my taste. Luckily, TWSBI nibs can be swapped out. The XF nib on a TWSBI is comparable to a 0.5mm gel pen to my eyes.

Sailor may be another brand worth checking for a fine width nib on their fountain pens. I have the Sailor Clear Candy in the medium nib which is comparable to a Lamy fine nib in terms of width so the Sailor fine is going to give a fine line for sure.

In the European pens, Lamy, Kaweco and TWSBI all offer XF nib widths which give a fairly fine line but I wouldn’t describe them as “razor fine” as I would the Uni-Ball Signo Bit gel pen.

Budget Fountain Pen comparison sample

Other factors can contribute to how bold or fine your lines look with a fountain pen. Paper quality can affect how thick your lines look. Good paper will keep the ink from seeping into the paper and bleeding the line widths. Also, the viscosity of the ink you are using can contribute to your line widths and overall ink flow. Some fountain pen inks are more liquid-y than others. I find that De Atramentis inks do very well in my finer nib pens as the inks feel more liquid-y. Diamine inks seem a bit stiffer which is great for stub nibs and wider widths but sometimes clog up my razor fine pens.

Did that help or just confuse the issue?

Link Love: Random Loves

Downloadable headers for your Facebook page (via How About Orange)
Downloadable headers for your Facebook page (via How About Orange)

Pens and Pencils

Notebooks

Bar-à-encres570-2
Georges & Co stationery shop in Paris features a fountain pen ink bar where inks can be custom mixed. (via Felt & Wire)

Scout Books Giveaway Winners!

scoutbooks rainbow

Today, everyone is a winner! Scout Books has kindly offered discounts for everyone.

All my awesome readers can take $25 off a custom order of Make Your Own Books or Notebooks with the promo code AWESOME. So that lightbulb, Keep Calm and Make Lists and all the other wonderful suggestions can be made for $25 less. There is currently no expiration date on this offer so start planning your custom design and then get a deal when you’re ready to make it. How awesome!
If you’re not ready to go all DIY, you can take  $10 off any order over $50 from the Bookstore by entering the code WELLAPPTDESK. This offers expire on 4/11/13.
Winners of the Rainbow Composition Set or the 3-pack of blank books are:
First up:
Screen Shot 2013-03-12 at 6.40.46 AM
Thetech207 is the first number drawn. He will have the right to pick between the two offers and then I will contact winner #2 who will get the alternate prize.
Screen Shot 2013-03-12 at 6.42.16 AM
Allie is the second winner and I will be contacting both winners today to claim their prizes.
Congrats to everyone!!!

Fountain Pen Exhibit Prep

Vintage Esterbrooks

On Friday, I helped two of my co-workers set up a display in our gallery area of fountain pens. I didn’t have nearly as many to add to the collection as they did but it was fun to see all the pens and touch them. There are vintage hard rubber pens, a TON of Esterbrooks, Parker, Sheaffer and many others. I have one case filled with modern fountain pens (most featured here on the blog).

The show will be in the gallery at Hallmark HQ for the month of March. If you are in the KC area and would like to see the show during regular business hours, let me know and I can give you a tour. If not, I’ll be posting photos soon of the show once it’s all set up.

A few vintage pens

Uni Kura Toga Mechanical Pencil

Uni KuraToga writing sample

My pal Brad over at Pen Addict always refers to the Uni Kuru Toga mechanical pencil as his pencil of choice so I finally decided I’d give it a try. The feature that makes this mechanical pencil unique is a automatic lead rotation so that you do not have to continually alter your grip to avoid getting a wide chisel effect.

The pencil body is plastic painted to look metallic and the grip area is clear plastic with some ridges to aid in gripping. There is a small ring of rubber just above the tip that must be designed to keep your fingers from slipping on the plastic body into the tip writing area. Overall, I love the color but this is not the most comfortable pencil for long session writing. For that, I would prefer the Pilot Opt with its large rubberized grip area.

The Kuru Toga pencil includes a small white plastic eraser under the translucent cap which works well and the cap keeps the eraser clean and free from bottom-of-the-bag debris.

Uni KuraToga close-up

There is a spring-loaded clutch in the pencil that is triggered every time you lift the pencil helping to rotate the lead to a perfect point as you write. I test drove the 0.5mm green model though there are 0.3mm lead versions of the pencil as well for an even finer line which would be good to tight technical drawings or other detailed work.

Uni KuraToga close-up

The image above is a writing sample from the Kuru Toga. There does seem to be an overall consistency in the line widths. I worked hard not to adjust my grip on the pencil while I was writing. Its a hard habit to break.

Zebra pencil writing close-up

This is a sample of my writing using a standard big-box mechanical pencil with a 0.5mm lead. I wrote with this without rotating the pencil while I wrote an lo and behold, the writing does get much thicker and more indistinct as a result of the pencil lead wearing into a chisel point.

If a consistent line width with your pencil is an issue, then the Kuru Toga line is definitely the answer. Available from JetPens for $7.50 for either the 0.5mm or 0.3mm versions.