Fountain Pen Review: Sailor ProColor Stardust

When I saw the Sailor Procolor 500 Shikisai Fountain Pen in Hoshikuzu (Stardust) with Fine Nib ($60) come up on JetPens, I jumped at the chance to try it out. It looks like the Sailor 1911 regular with a steel nib and it was available in the black sparkle Stardust finish that I had wanted in the ProGear Slim but was only available as a limited edition a few years ago and is impossible to find now. I was curious if a Sailor steel nib would be up to snuff.

When it arrived, I was pleased that it was as pretty as I had hoped. It is not as sparkly as my ProGear Pink Love but not as subtle as the Purple Lamé.  It looks like stars in the night sky.

The nib looks almost identical to the nibs on a ProGear Slim or regular 1911 without the 14K markings. It has the filigree around the edge of the nib, the “1911” and anchor and the “Sailor” logo branding at the bottom.

The ProColor is a bit lighter than a 1911 standard at 18gms capped with the cartridge. My 1911 weight 21gms but it has a converter which I suspect is adding the additional 3gms. Uncapped, the ProColor weighs just 10gms. The cap does post for writing and is fairly well-balanced.

Look! A new weight chart! Pens are weighed filled with ink (in the case of the TWSBIs) or with a full converter.

Sizewise, the ProColor is identical to the 1911 regular and just a bit shorter and slimmer than a Lamy Safari/Al-Star. The ProColor is just a little longer than the ProGear Slim but the same width.

After looking at the Delike knock-offs, I can see where some of the design cues came from for the New Moon. The ProColor cap has the silver hardware all the way to edge of the cap and the clip is not as graceful as the 1911. Its definitely straddling the line between the higher end 1911 and the knock-off New Moon. Of course, there’s the plus of the Sailor steel nib.

And the nib is what I really wanted to experience and what really took me by surprise because its been years since I tried a lower end Sailor nib. Very early in my fountain pen days, I tried a Sailor Clear Candy but I had very little point of reference and I feel I should probably go back and look at that pen again now that I know what a bit more about pens. I can’t recall the specifics of my experience now other than it was an inexpensive plastic pen. The ProColor, however, was a delight. It was comparable and in many instances surpassed the experience I’ve had with similarly priced TWSBIs.

Because its a Japanese nib, it writes like a western EF (hence the error in my written tests) but its actually a Sailor fine nib. It is a buttery smooth steel nib. I was quite delighted with how well it wrote. For the price point, this is an excellent fountain pen.

After reviewing the knock-off versions of Sailors earlier this week, I love having the chance to recommend to save your pennies for the real thing. It’s worth it. This pen feels better built, the nib is beautiful and, heck, it even comes with the Sailor box, warranty and two proprietary cartridges (converter needs to be purchased separately).

DISCLAIMER: This item was sent to me free of charge by JetPens for the purpose of review. Please see the About page for more details.

Written by

11 comments / Add your comment below

  1. Such a pretty pen! Reminds me of my Jinhao x750 Sparkling Sands. I’ve been daydreaming of the Sailor Fresca Robin’s Egg Blue, but the budget didn’t allow for it. I might be able to swing the $60 for this beauty and get to try my first Sailor fountain pen!

  2. How does this Sailor steel F compare to a Pilot Metropolitan or Prera F? I have a Sailor Lecoule, but this looks like a completely different (and much nicer) nib.

    1. As I commented to Ruru, this is definitely a higher end nib than the nib on the Clear Candy or LeCoule. It’s a bit wider than the Metropolitan or Prera F but I think its because its not quite as stiff. I’ll have to do a few side-by-side comparisons to be sure though.

  3. hmm I wonder if Sailor has improved its steel nibs in recent years? I bought a clear candy way back when too, and it had such a terrible nib (scratchy + dry + prone to non-starting) that it turned me off Sailor for years. The design definitely looks much closer to its gold brethren than the plain steel one the clear candy had though :|a I might have to shell out for this one since the finish is sooo pretty.

    1. I definitely think this is a higher end nib than the one used on the Clear Candy model. The nib is both styled and cut more like the higher end ProGear and 1911 nibs. And I completely agree. My first experience with Sailor was a Clear Candy and this is not at all like that.

  4. Oh, sooo pretty… love that starry finish! Just made for a Field Notes Night Sky! The only Sailors I have are the high-end gold fude, the low-end steel fude and the Clear Candy, so it’s good to know where this steel nib is by comparison.


      1. Not surprising, the Shimmering Sands is aluminum and not a resin XD
        I like both materials, sometimes I’m in the mood for a heavy pen, sometimes not.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.