The Pilot E95s ($176) is a pen I’ve always considered purchasing but kept holding back. A lot of the higher end Pilot fountain pens with gold nibs can be too soft for an overwriting left handed writers because we PUSH the pen when we write, we compress the tines of the softer Pilot 14k nibs.
I had a long chat with Bill, the fountain pen sales rep for Pilot, on the way to the airport in Dallas about his favorite pen. He confessed that he’s been keeping an E95s with an EF nib in his shirt pocket for years. So, when I saw him a few weeks later at the Nashville On The Paper Trail event, I asked to try the E95s with the EF nib. He handed me the sample he had in his tray. I said “No, can I see your E95s?” He laughed and pulled his pen out of his shirt pocket. I wanted to see how a decade or more of wear might have affected this plastic barrel pen. Guess what? Without a case or sleeve, Bill’s pen looked practically brand new.
I asked if I could try writing with his pen and, kind man that he is, said yes. And even after decades, it wrote beautifully. The EF nib is fine enough to write on any paper since it doesn’t lay down a ton of ink and the slip cap makes opening and closing the pen fast and convenient for everyday use.

Check out that nib! So delicate and fine!
Writing Samples:

I tested the E95s on my standard Tomoe River 68 gsm notebook (from Odyssey Notebooks) and the fine nib has a bit of feedback and felt similar to my EF Sailor Pro Gear Slim nibs. Not everyone will like the feedback of the EF nib but they might not like how fine the EF nib anyway. But be aware, the Pilot E95s in the EF nib is a little scritchy. If you want a smoother experience, look for a F or M nib instead.

I really wanted to be able to use the Pilot E95s, which is quite portable, with my Mark’s EDiT B7 semi and I think its a good match. The NEO AGENDA for EDiT paper is quite similar to Tomoe River paper since its thin, light and fountain pen friendly. I also wanted to compare the line widths that make it clear that even if a pen says its EF, doesn’t mean they are all the same width. Assume this is “vanity sizing” for fountain pens.
Compared to the Jinhao 59:

I reviewed the Jinhao 59 (not 95… but 59, get it?!?!) awhile back and sort of inspired me to reconsider the Pilot E95s because the Jinhao 59 EF is not a Japanese EF. But there are a few other major differences.
Both are slip caps and roughly the same size both capped and posted.

The E95s nib cutaway is different. The nib appears larger and is more exposed with a more interesting cutaway. There is a more noticeable step between the plastic of the grip and the nib on the Jinhao. The smooth transition between the nib and grip on the E95s is elegant. The Jinhao 59 is a litte more clunky. Temper your expectations for a pen that costs $20.
Of course, the E95s has a gold nib versus the steel nib in the Jinhao. Pilot doesn’t offer an E95s with a steel nib so in order to have a slip cap, lightweight portable pen from Pilot, you will have to go with the gold nib. I know! The hardship! But the gold nib is beautiful and the quality is exceptional.

In the close-up above, you can see how much wider the Jinhao nib is compared to the E95s.
Conclusion:
In our current market, being able to get a 14K nib for under $200 makes the E95s is a decent investment. If you really want a fine, portable pen, the Pilot E95s with an EF nib is going to be a great option for you. And as Bill proved, even being used everyday for a decade, the E95s stands up to daily use. If you are concerned that the EF will be too scratchy for you, then this is not for you. I recommend trying the Fine or Medium nib at your local pen shop or next stationery event as that might be more to your taste.
But Pilot remains a great brand with quality products but prices continue to creep up so if this was a pen you were considering buying, I wouldn’t wait.
DISCLAIMER: Some items included in this review were purchased with the generous support of our Patrons for the purpose of review. Please see the About page for more details.
