Last week I decided to take on the challenge to use only “starter pens” for a week. I picked out all the Platinum Preppy pens I have and a franken-Pilot Prera. I tried to follow a similar process to Derek’s original challenge but had to modify it a little bit to make the challenge work for me and make sure that I could stick with it for a whole week.
Overall, I didn’t do as much writing or drawing as I’d hoped to do last week but I did use the “starter pens” throughout the week — I put my fancy, higher-end pens out of reach and only had the Platinum Preppys and the Pilot Prera (similar to a Pilot Kakuno in terms of nib material and size). I talked a bit with Derek who created this challenge and we both laughed that using what I have (specifically my franke-Pilot) is a great solution to the challenge.
One of the things I discovered is that the Platinum Preppy with the 03 nib is too wide for the small Hobonichi and Stalogy grid papers — at least for me. The 02 Extra Fine Platinum nib worked well for me but I only had one Platinum with this nib. The Pilot F nib which was installed in my Prera was fine enough to use with the tiny grid in my planners. What’s surprising is that the 02 EF Platinum nib is about the same width as the Pilot F. So, if you prefer wider nibs, go for the Platinum 03 or a Pilot M. I’m surprised I didn’t notice this difference sooner.

The slip-n-seal caps of the Platinum meant there was never a hard start. Okay, that’s a lie. I have one dud Platinum. I think I let ink dry in it and cleaned it twice and still couldn’t get it to perform consistently. So, life lesson — clean your pens regularly. I will need to pull out my sonic cleaner and see if I can get it going again. It was my spare black ink Platinum and the wider 03 nib so I didn’t really miss it from the rotation.
I am glad I went ahead and syringe-filled the cartridges (or scavenged a converter) for these pens so I could use the ink colors I’d selected for my September planners and keep the overall look and feel of my planner, even though I switched pens mid-month.
As this week has come to an end, I’ve decided to continue using these pens through the end of the month. I’ve enjoyed using these little gems. Yes, the Prera breaks the below $20 level of the other “start pens” but since I didn’t own a Kakuno, it was the closest substitute for the challenge and provided me the finer nib size that I prefer overall.

All of that said, I think we tend to put a lot of prestige on higher-priced, fancier fountain pens but this week proved to me that these budget-starter pens still bring a lot to the table. I hope it makes getting in to fountain pens less financially intimidating if someone is just starting out. These are GOOD pens.

I enjoyed this challenge so much I confess I did place an order for a couple of Pilot Kakunos so that I can try this again with the true “starter pens.”
Its not necessary to have under-$20 fountain pens to do this challenge. If you only have Kaweco Sports or Lamy Safaris, you can try this challenge with those pens as well. You could even use a combination of whatever “starter pens” you bought early in your fountain pen life. Do you like them as much as you did when you first discovered fountain pens? Do they still fill you with that sense of joy and adventure or have you realized that the nibs or shape isn’t your favorite? Its such a fun experiment. Let me know in the comments if you try this yourself.